Policy Owners

Own Universal Life? Why Cost-of-Insurance Lawsuits Matter

New lawsuits challenge how insurers set cost-of-insurance charges on universal life. What those charges are, and five things every policy owner should check.

Universal life insurance is back in the headlines, and not for a good reason. A wave of lawsuits is challenging how some carriers calculate cost-of-insurance (COI) charges, the monthly fee deducted from a universal life policy to pay for the death benefit. Industry coverage this month pointed to disputes involving Farmers and Brighthouse, alongside a proposed $147.5 million settlement from Lincoln (InsuranceNewsNet).

Lincoln's own SEC filings describe that settlement as a $147.5 million pre-tax cash payment to class members. The underlying claims allege the company charged more in non-guaranteed cost of insurance than the policies permitted (Lincoln annual report). These are allegations in court, and insurers generally dispute them. Still, if you own any kind of universal life policy, it's a good moment to look at yours.

What a cost-of-insurance charge is

Unlike whole life, a universal life policy separates the cost of insurance from your cash value. Each month the insurer deducts a COI charge and other fees, then credits interest to what's left. Most policies list a guaranteed maximum COI rate, while the insurer charges a lower "current" rate that it may raise within the contract's limits.

When COI rates rise, especially at older ages, cash value can drain faster than expected. If the cash value runs out, the policy can lapse unless you pay more.

Five things every UL owner should check

  1. Request an in-force illustration. It projects how your policy will perform from today, at current charges and crediting rates. It's free from your insurer.
  2. Find the year your policy could lapse. Look for the first year cash value hits zero under current assumptions, and again under guaranteed assumptions.
  3. Compare this year's statement to last year's. A jump in monthly deductions without a change in coverage is worth asking about.
  4. Check any no-lapse guarantee. Some policies stay in force as long as you meet a minimum premium. Missing even a few payments can void it.
  5. Ask about your options. You may be able to raise premiums, lower the death benefit, use a 1035 exchange into a newer policy, or keep it as is.

Should you be worried?

Most universal life policies perform exactly as designed. Problems usually come from older policies bought when interest rates were much higher, from indexed or variable policies that were underfunded from the start, or from COI increases late in life. The fix is almost always the same: review early, while you still have options.

Before you replace anything

Don't cancel a policy before new coverage is approved and in force. Your age and health today may mean a replacement costs more, or isn't available. Compare carefully, and look at guaranteed universal life or whole life if you want fewer moving parts.

Want a second opinion on an existing universal life policy? Send us a message and an advisor will walk through your in-force illustration with you.

lifeinsurans.com is an independent quote-comparison and lead-generation website, not an insurance company or agency. We compare quotes and information from top-rated insurance carriers and connect consumers with independently licensed insurance agents, who may contact you about your request. Each agent is individually licensed in the states where they do business. Quotes are estimates; final coverage and rates are set by the insurer after underwriting. Content is educational only, not financial, legal or tax advice. Carrier names and logos belong to their owners and do not imply endorsement.