The best company
is the one that fits you.
There’s no single “best” life insurer. The right company depends on what you’re buying and how each carrier views your health. Start with financial strength, then match products and underwriting to your situation.
What we look at
- Financial strength from independent agencies such as AM Best, S&P, Moody's and Fitch.
- Product fit: term conversion options, whole life dividend history, IUL caps and charges.
- Underwriting: how the carrier treats common conditions, and no-exam options.
- Service and claims: complaint data from the NAIC and real claim experience.
Read our full review methodology.
Carrier matchups
Side-by-side comparisons of the most-searched insurers.
MassMutual vs. New York Life
How MassMutual and New York Life compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →MassMutual vs. Prudential
How MassMutual and Prudential compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →MassMutual vs. Nationwide
How MassMutual and Nationwide compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →Nationwide vs. New York Life
How Nationwide and New York Life compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →Nationwide vs. Guardian
How Nationwide and Guardian compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →Prudential vs. New York Life
How Prudential and New York Life compare on structure, products and fit.
Read →Policy comparisons
Rankings & reviews
Top 10 Life Insurance Tips
Ten things every buyer should know before choosing a life insurance company or policy — from conversion options to beneficiary mistakes.
Read →How We Review Companies
Our methodology for reviewing and comparing life insurance companies: financial strength, products, underwriting, pricing and customer service.
Read →Client Reviews
Read reviews from lifeinsurans clients in New York, New Jersey, Florida, Texas and California about comparing quotes and getting covered.
Read →Frequently asked questions
Which life insurance company pays claims the most reliably?
Large, highly rated insurers generally have strong claims records. The NAIC publishes complaint ratios you can use to compare service.
We compare top-rated carriers
Logos are trademarks of their respective owners. Carrier availability varies by state and product.


